The Four Ways to Do Pompeii from Naples
Every listing on this page is a variation on four decisions, and the price gaps between them are smaller than they look once you count what each one leaves out.
A guided half day, transport included
The default. A van or coach collects you in central Naples between eight and nine in the morning, drives twenty-five to forty minutes depending on traffic and where you start, and hands you to a guide for two hours inside the walls. You are back in the city by early afternoon with the rest of the day intact.
Two hours is the honest figure for what a guide can cover: the Forum with Vesuvius framed behind it, the Stabian Baths, a bakery, a thermopolium counter, the Lupanare, one or two houses and the plaster casts. It is not enough for the amphitheatre at the far eastern end, and it is not enough for the Villa of the Mysteries, which sits outside the walls fifteen minutes past the Porta Ercolano.
The three half days here cost $60, $62 and $70 and differ mainly in where they start. The $62 option meets at the Starhotels Terminus door opposite Napoli Centrale, which is the easiest instruction to follow if you are arriving by train. The $60 coach includes pickup but only guarantees a live guide when six people book the same departure.
A full day with Vesuvius
Adding the volcano turns a half day into seven or eight hours and roughly doubles the walking. The standard shape is Vesuvius first, in the cooler part of the morning, then a sit-down lunch, then Pompeii in the afternoon — which is the wrong way round for heat but the right way round for the shuttle buses that run up the volcano road.
The climb from the car park to the crater rim is about an hour and a half on loose volcanic gravel with no shade. The national park charges its own entry, quoted by two of these operators at €11 to €11.68 per person, and it closes without warning in bad weather. The port-pickup day tour is the only listing that says what happens then: your park ticket is refunded, or on the audio-guide option you are taken to the MAP virtual museum in Pompeii instead.
A full day with Herculaneum
The other second site, and the better one for anybody who has already walked a Roman street. Herculaneum was buried by a pyroclastic surge rather than falling pumice, which carbonised wood instead of crushing it: upper floors, roof beams, doors, a bed frame, a wooden screen. It is a tenth the size of Pompeii and you can see most of it in two hours.
Three tours here pair the two cities, and they are set out side by side further down, with prices, inclusions and the catch on each. The short version: the best-rated of them carries an archaeologist rather than a host, and it also schedules a stop at a shopping outlet between the two sites. Compare the two-site days.
Getting there yourself
The one the tour pages do not want you to price. A Circumvesuviana return from Naples to Pompei Scavi is €6.60, and a guide waiting at the gate comes with the entry ticket already inside the price — a guided visit for roughly a third less than the cheapest coach package. The full sum is in the cost table.
What you give up is the door-to-door part: a suburban commuter train that is hot, crowded and occasionally struck, with no luggage space and a walk of about a hundred metres from the platform to Porta Marina at the other end. What you gain is a start time you choose and no minimum group size to satisfy.
The round-trip shuttle sits awkwardly between the two. It is comfortable and it leaves from Largo Castello, but it runs only twice a day and it includes no park ticket — so it costs several times the train fare to solve a problem the train already solves.